Why adaptation is not a climate strategy

I heard a news story recently about some local communities seeking funding to help protect their shorelines from rising sea levels.  It made me grit my teeth a bit. 

Why?  I have nothing against those communities, of course, or their well-founded concerns about rising sea levels (because unfortunately there’s plenty of that to come).

No, I get upset when I hear about adapting to climate change without any corresponding effort to mitigate climate change.

What’s the difference between the two?  Adaptation is learning to live in new circumstances or with new realities brought about by climate change – such as rising sea levels and more storm surges.  Mitigation is taking action to prevent climate change in the first place.  If you mitigate effectively, there is no need for adaptation.

Here are three analogies that I hope can better illustrate that difference:

  • If your house catches fire, adaptation is thinking ahead to how you will live without a house; mitigation is trying to put out the fire and save the house.
  • If your home has a leaky roof, adaptation is putting out pails to catch drips every time it rains – and putting out more each time because the leaks will get worse.  Mitigation is fixing the roof so there is no need for pails.
  • If you came home and found the sink overflowing because you’d left the tap on, adaptation would be mopping up the water or installing a drain in your floor.  Mitigation would be turning off the tap.

If you’re like me, it’s obvious what you would do in each of the above situations.  Yet in the world around us, so many initiatives focus on adapting to climate change rather than mitigating it in the first place:

  • Bigger storms?  Install bigger culverts.
  • More wildfires?  Buy more fire trucks and water bombers.
  • Hotter temperatures?  Install air conditioning (which ironically uses more of the energy causing climate change in the first place).

It’s true that we’ve already gone far enough down the road of climate change that some adaptation is necessary (like shoreline protection).  But until we stop what’s causing climate change in the first place – in other words, mitigate – we’re on a non-stop treadmill of constant, never-ending adaptation – which is expensive, inconvenient and even dangerous.

And what does mitigation actually mean?  Here are five Golden Rules:

  1. Doing everything possible to reduce our consumption of oil, coal and fossil gas (AKA natural gas)
  2. Doing everything possible to get our energy from renewable, non-emitting sources like hydro, solar and wind, backed up by batteries
  3. Switching to electric vehicles as quickly as possible
  4. Switching to heat pumps for heating as quickly as possible
  5. Being energy efficient in everything we do

Something to think about (and something I wish our leaders would think more about).

Share This Post

More to Explore